The 244th clash between Liverpool and Manchester United ended in a draw, leaving both sides with mixed emotions. This high-stakes match revealed weaknesses but also offered valuable insights for both teams.
Manchester United: Gains and Concerns
For United, escaping Anfield with a point was a significant breakthrough, especially after a string of disappointing results. Many fans had feared a crushing defeat on hostile ground, but the match proved that form and rankings don’t always dictate the outcome of a rivalry. Attitude and on-the-spot performance were key, and this game showcased one of manager Amorim’s best tactical displays since taking charge.
Boost in Confidence
United had been winless in their last 10 clashes against the other “Big Six” clubs. However, back-to-back strong results—beating Manchester City in the derby and now holding top-of-the-table Liverpool to a draw—have reignited belief among players and fans alike. The team’s fighting spirit has become a beacon of hope.
A More Stable Lineup
United’s starting XI is finally taking shape, requiring only minor tweaks. While the squad initially struggled to adapt to Amorim’s 3-4-3 system, key players like Ugarte and Mainoo have stepped up to solidify the midfield, enhancing both defensive strength and coverage.
That said, some vulnerabilities remain. For example, right center-back Matthijs de Ligt was directly involved in both goals conceded, raising questions about his ability to handle aerial threats. Moving him to left center-back against physically strong opponents could be a solution.
Additionally, Bruno Fernandes’ positional flexibility has become a tactical asset. In this match, he shifted from left-wing to central areas to exploit Trent Alexander-Arnold’s defensive lapses—a move that paid off. If United can strengthen their left-wing-back or forward options during the winter transfer window (as rumored with Victor Osimhen), the team will be even more formidable.
Concern: Sustainability of High-Energy Play
United’s intense playing style is a double-edged sword. With the season entering a grueling phase of matches across three competitions, stamina and squad depth will be severely tested. Failing to maintain consistent quality could lead to instability.
Liverpool: Problems to Address and Positives to Build On
Liverpool had a strong start to the season, but this match exposed two critical issues:
Alexander-Arnold’s Struggles
Trent Alexander-Arnold had a disastrous game, with United repeatedly targeting his flank to create opportunities. In contrast, substitute Conor Bradley delivered a solid performance on both ends of the pitch, even overshadowing Alexander-Arnold. Manager Slot might need to rethink his starting lineup if these inconsistencies continue.
Inconsistent Tempo and Fitness Management
Liverpool’s performance fluctuated significantly between the first and second halves. Their “slow start, strong finish” strategy hasn’t always worked, and opponents are starting to exploit this pattern. Furthermore, with Darwin Núñez yet to find his form, the team lacks a reliable threat against compact defenses or aerial duels. Tactical adjustments are necessary to address these gaps.
Reasons for Optimism
Despite the challenges, Liverpool still showed resilience. They have come from behind to earn points seven times this season, losing just once in those games and clawing back a total of 13 points.
Cody Gakpo’s consistent contributions have added a new dimension to the attack, while the return of Ibrahima Konaté and Conor Bradley has reduced the team’s injury concerns. If Liverpool can secure a veteran defensive midfielder during the winter window (with Martín Zubimendi being a rumored target), they’ll further enhance their ability to compete on multiple fronts.
Conclusion
This fiercely contested Red Derby, while ending in a draw, offered plenty of takeaways for both sides.
- For Manchester United: They’ve gained confidence and a more stable lineup but must address the sustainability of their high-energy tactics.
- For Liverpool: Defensive lapses and tactical adjustments need urgent attention, but the team’s depth and resilience remain strong points.
As the season progresses, this match could serve as a pivotal moment for both teams, shaping their campaigns in the months to come.